Gender Bender 1×13: On a scale of 1 – 10… she was a kind 3.

Marco! Polo!

There’s open-ended and then there’s makes-no-sense. If the answer to its mystery was merely vague, this episode might have a different reputation. That being said, I by no means dislike it. “Gender Bender” is a guilty pleasure for me. It’s not among the general Phile favorites, in fact, it’s almost universally panned. But one thing is certain: even if you don’t like it, you’ll be thinking about it afterward if only because you’re too confused to move on. Besides being a puzzle, “Gender Bender” actually has an interesting premise. After all, sex is scary. People are at their most vulnerable physically, emotionally and psychologically during sex. At the very least, this episode serves as a sort of Public Service Announcement: Find out their name first, please.

This may have been an early attempt by The Powers That Be to make the show sexy, and in that respect it does fail. I know I first watched this at a very innocent age 14 but it took me a while to catch on that Scully is aroused. Somehow, the face on aroused Scully just doesn’t convey, well, arousal. She looks more like a child who lost her dolly than a woman lost to passion. I realize it’s because she’s trying to fight the feeling off, but still. On top of that, maybe it wasn’t the best idea to show the evil villain running around in women’s underwear. It… well… de-villainizes him. The club scenes too are laughable in retrospect. The introduction of Nicholas Lea is their only saving grace.

Let’s admit the truth. The alien angle feels like a cop out. It falls out of the sky like a UFO over Roswell. You feel cheated not because you don’t see it coming, but because when it does come it doesn’t make any sense. The end isn’t one of those moments where you look back, smack your forehead and cry, “Of course!” a la The Sixth Sense. Now, I’m going to admit that I’ve cheated a little and read another draft of the script in which Mulder suspects that The Kindred are alien long before the end of the episode. It still doesn’t work. Truth be told, this episode would have played out better if aliens had nothing to do with the matter. Lethal sex is scary enough on it’s own. This episode takes place in the early ‘90s when AIDS was still all over the news. The concept of sex with a stranger proving immediately fatal would have grabbed an audience all by its pretty lonesome. No EBEs required.

The implication is that these aliens don’t have sex. They have no children. Whatever transformation Brother Aaron goes through in the barn must be a form of self-reproduction. Or rather, since they can regenerate by changing sexes, there’s no real need to reproduce at all but only regenerate. The Kindred are the same as they were 100 years ago. If The Kindred merely suffered from a genetic mutation that required an almost religious abstinence and separation from the world on their part, isn’t that enough of an X-File? That would explain their resistance to outsiders. Their self-imposed isolation is then merely a self-sacrificial attempt to protect the rest of society. Now that’s some angst. It also would make Marty a more evil villain by contrast, taking vengeance on a world that he can’t be a part of. Instead, we see too little of Marty in his (original?) male form. As a matter of fact, we’re never formally introduced to Marty’s male form and that’s a shame. And that brief monologue doesn’t serve to make him either a pathetic or a villainous creature.

The true star of this episode is all that Vancouver rain. The atmosphere the rain inadvertently creates is what keeps this episode afloat. It’s also what makes us think we should be afraid even when the plot doesn’t make sense. Mulder’s scenes in the tunnels also make for more visual fun. Surely whatever is missing in the story got added to the cinematography under the skillful hands of Rob Bowman who, by the way, made his directorial debut on the show with this episode.

And the Verdict is…

If “Beyond the Sea” (1×12) proved that The X-Files could be emotional, “Gender Bender” certainly doesn’t prove that it can be sexy. (For that matter, The X-Files did best when it stayed away from sex in all but the vaguest of terms.) I do like the fact that this is a low-tech episode. Whether because of budgetary concerns or not, it forces the audience to pay attention to the story and not the gizmos. (CSI, please take notes… and then pass them around when you’re done.) It also forces the investigators to do some real legwork and not rely on leads too easily gleaned from an obviously made up national network of information. (Still looking your way, CSI.) Most of all, the atmosphere created by the deft hands of Mr. Bowman is enough to make us feel that something darkly exciting is happening. Vancouver isn’t too shabby either.

Maybe Chris Carter, in his defense of this episode, was right about the value of an open-ended ending. Despite the nitpicking I’ve done here, I actually like “Gender Bender”. In fact, it’s the first X-Files episode I can remember actually sitting down and watching. Up until this point, I had only seen glimpses. This was the summer FX started showing reruns and my dad had it on. When it ended, I remember standing in front of the TV going, “What does it all mean?? What in the heck kind of show is this?” with my face the perfect picture of perplexity. Frustrating? Sure. But hey, it made me want to keep tuning in.  I certainly tried not to miss an episode after that. I wanted to know if The X-Files was really that weird.

So if you have yet to watch it, don’t let confusion ruin the experience, rather embrace it. And if you’ve already dismissed it, tune back in, relish the randomness and let disappointment roll off you like water down Scully’s trenchcoat.

In other news: Your mother’s warnings about having sex with strangers? All true.



Mulder and Scully relinquish their guns to a group of people of which one is probably a murderer. Are they already doped up on pheromones??

If the aliens can be physically aroused by as well as arouse humans, why can’t they just have sex with each other for fun if not procreation? They must have the hormones to enjoy it after all, or can assume them, anyway. Why can they enjoy sex with us but not with each other? I could keep going…

If we can’t be sure that human’s can produce pheromones, can humans contain them either? How is it that extraterrestrials secrete animal hormones mixed with human DNA? Why don’t the pheromones kill during sex rather than after? Again, I could keep going…

We know that their genderbending has something to do with regeneration, so do they just keep alternating between their male and female forms for all eternity? One gets tired so they bring in the other version off the bench?? Are these just the forms they take while on earth or is this like Star Trek where all aliens are humanoid? Still going…

Random Musings:

Our first, last and only X-Files crop circle. Amen.

“It’s hard to imagine this day and age someone having sex with a perfect stranger.” Really, Scully??? Is it now? Because I seem to remember a certain episode in Season 4…

How about those early ‘90s morphing techniques, eh? That shot where Marty/Martina turns his head to morph looks like it came straight out of the music video for Black or White.

There were some plot points that made more sense in the previous version of the script. For instance, the aliens needed some material that was much easier to mine on earth’s surface. Hence, The Kindred were known for making stoneware pottery with clay they mined themselves. This clay was only found locally, but I guess whatever planet they were from had a shortage. That’s logical, I suppose.

Best Quotes:

Scully: So, what is our profile of the killer? Indeterminate height, weight, sex; unarmed, but extremely attractive?


Scully: There’s something up there, Mulder.
Mulder: Oh, I’ve been saying that for years.

17 responses to “Gender Bender 1×13: On a scale of 1 – 10… she was a kind 3.

  1. For some reason I always have a soft spot for this episode, despite as you point out, the gaping holes in the plot. I think it’s because I know it would have had so much potential if small tidbits had been changed or altered. Also I think the episode is quite successful in being downright creepy once Mulder and Scully embark on finding the Kindred community. The scenes with Marty/Martina overall held less interest for me- they were just too cringeworthy!
    The alternative ideas you mention would have certainly made this episode more memorable and spooky, but as it is, whenever Nicholas Lea first comes on the scene I can’t help but smirk with embarassment. And the terrible house techno that thumps throughout the club scenes really date the piece, though I’m sure that couldn’t be helped.
    Sorry to be shallow, but perhaps it would have been more ‘sexy’ if the Kindred brother that tries to seduce Scully was slightly more attractive or simply alluring? He looked like he wanted to lock her in the basement rather than ravish her.
    But as you say, if the real explanation had been explored or changed it might have worked better. Afterall, “smart is sexy”!

    • It really is creepy, isn’t it? It’s promise just doesn’t quite pan out in the end. But, like you, I can forgive it that for letting me enjoy the ride. And, hey, being puzzled is better than being bored like I was with Space or irritated like I am with The Field Where I Died.

  2. That genderbending chick always gave me the heebie jeebies. They probably couldn’t have casted a girl that would have had a more creepy quality than the one they went with. Also, I can totally see why they gave Nicholas Lea a recurring role in the show after this episode mostly on the strength of his awesome reaction when he sort of snickers and tells them that “she” ended up being a he.

  3. ““It’s hard to imagine this day and age someone having sex with a perfect stranger.” Really, Scully??? Is it now? Because I seem to remember a certain episode in Season 4…”

    So when did you change your opinion and decide that Scully didn’t have sex with Jerse? 😀

  4. This episode really had potential, but the gaps in the plot and the inconsistencies ruined it a bit, to me. It’s too bad that they involved the aliens instead of sticking with “different” people, withdrawn from our modern societies, and the mistery around that. This episode, even if I like it anyway, really always leaves me with disapointment.

  5. Im rewatching the series from the beginning with my girlfriend who has never taken the trip. Fortunately I found your website after the pilot and am thoroughly enjoying reading your reviews after watching each episode.
    In my memory (been about 5 years since I last went through the show) I would have said Space was the weakest episode of season 1. Going through again I would say this is a strong contender to steal the crown. Disjointed, slow and with potentially the most abrupt and implausible ending that the X files ever produced. A couple of one liners (both mentioned in your review) and the general performances of the leads being the only saving grace.
    Your insights into the show have warmed my heart and made me smile so far, but how you could give this episode a higher rating than ‘fallen angel’ is beyond me! 🙂
    Cant wait to read the rest of your reviews though, as they really are heightening my enjoyment of one of my favourite shows of all time. Sad to see you stop during season 7 and hope everything is ok in your world

  6. Pingback: The Gift 8×11: Are you calling Mulder a liar? | Musings of an X-Phile

  7. Totally agree with you on this one. What comes up out of the ground can be just as frightening as what comes down out of the sky. Those cellar scenes were… well, a bit icky, but also interesting. I think I’d have liked it a lot more if the inference had been that they came from some hole deep in the cellar, than from a space ship. Or if there simply hadn’t been an attempt at explanation at all.

    • Even the alien angle wasn’t much of an explanation. You know, endings like this were both what was so annoying and so intriguing about Season 1. I kept thinking, “What is with this show??”

  8. Great review, you captured pretty much everything I thought about this episode. It was equal parts confusing and terrifying and the ending left way more questions unanswered then answered (eg were the genderbending and excessive pheremone things linked any meaningful way?)

    • I can’t even read these old posts, they’re too embarrassing. But as embarrassing as this episode may be for 1013, I still love it. I rewatched it the day of the revival premiere and had as grand an old time as ever. Crazy? Yes. But crazy awesome.

  9. OK wait. at 37:06…this character is Krycek, right? RIGHT? Explain this nonsense to me

  10. This always struck me as an episode I won’t necessarily skip on the DVD, but it’s certainly not one of my favorites. Let’s just call this wasted potential and move on.

  11. I’m not particularly one way or the other about this episode. There are things that I like (such as that little scene when frustrated Mulder crumples up his map and kicks it, and Scully catches it. That was a cute moment between them), a few things that don’t make sense. I think they ruined it at the end by making them aliens. Without any exposition or correlating evidence, it doesn’t hold up, especially since that would me them yet another completely different species of alien from all the ones we later learn about.

    I remember when I first watched this episode I got very confused between all the different Kindred members. I think it would have been far more effective if Brother Martin and Brother Andrew had been the same person. It would make a better connection if the seducer/murderer Mulder and Scully were looking for ended up being the same person who tried to do the same to Scully, rather than it being a completely different member of the Kindred. How many of them were rebelling against their way of life? It started off as just one, and then two…were there more than that?

    I find your interpretation interesting, that the gender bending only happens at the end of their life so that they regenerate. I read it differently – that they could all gender bend at will, but doing so makes them sick, and that’s why Brother Martin had to be taken away and healed.

  12. “Somehow, the face on aroused Scully just doesn’t convey, well, arousal. She looks more like a child who lost her dolly than a woman lost to passion. I realize it’s because she’s trying to fight the feeling off…”

    Speaking of Scully, this is a very Scully-like thing to say! You make the observation, acknowledge that something weird is going on, and then… dismiss it with a Rational Explanation. Why not open yourself to the Extreme Possibility instead! I mean, you say that Scully doesn’t look like she’s sexually aroused. Might it not just be possible that that’s because… she isn’t?

You Know You Want To...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s