The Sixth Extinction 7×3: Some truths are not for you.

Don't be subtle or anything, Mulder.

It’s tough being a middle child and “The Sixth Extinction” is the somewhat forgotten child sandwiched between two attention-hungry siblings. “Biogenesis” (6×22) is about the origins of the universe while “The Sixth Extinction: Amor Fati” (7×4) contemplates the coming of the messiah. (Grandiose much?) Bracketed by such life-altering concepts, what job is left for “The Sixth Extinction” to take over?

What I like about this one is that it’s more action oriented than either of the other episodes. Between the plagues, the apparitions, the zombie… Chris Carter was clearly trying to bring the show back to its creepy roots and I appreciate that.

I also wholeheartedly welcome the return of Michael Kritschgau. One wonders what his character must have felt when, after all Kritchgau did for him, giving up his job and his reputation to testify for Mulder, Mulder stops listening to him and turns back to his alien ways. Briefly the thought crosses my mind, “Since when was his character involved in Remote Viewing experiments and since when did Mulder know that?” but it’s quickly hushed. Maybe Mulder can read minds from across the city. I don’t care. What’s a plot point or two between friends?

And some might find his scenes in the hospital with Mulder and Skinner boring, but I think they’re a lot of fun. It’s always a treat to see Skinner get in on the action and I believe his heavy presence here is a harbinger of things to come this season. He doesn’t get his own episode, per se, but he comes out from behind his desk in a major way. I’m also surprised to hear him admit so freely his belief that Mulder’s disease is extra-terrestrial and I suddenly realize that while Skinner’s been involved in the mythology of The X-Files since Season 1, he’s always been on the human side of the plot. To my recollection, he’s never said one way or the other whether he believes the Syndicate’s conspiracy was hiding the truth about alien life, though I suppose his support of Mulder all these years is evidence to that effect.

As for Mulder, I’m dying to know what he’s thinking now that he knows what everybody else is thinking. Ultimately, mind reading is a power I wouldn’t want. Some things are better not to know. But I relish the chance to experience it vicariously and watch Mulder waste away in (mostly) silent angst.

I may even have to rethink my position on that cut scene from “Biogenesis” where Mulder confronts Diana Fowley. Yes, that knock-down, drag-out would have been awesome. But if it had happened in the previous episode I would have been robbed of the thrill of realizing that when Mulder says, “They’re coming,” it’s Diana he’s referring to. Oh, how vindicated I still feel to finally know once and for all that he’s onto her.

Now we come to what I think is the most interesting part of this episode, and not just because I’m a Shipper. Carter sets up two scenes of bedside vigil for the dying Mulder, one with Diana Fowley and one with Scully. We’re invited to compare and contrast their reactions to Mulder’s condition, to the answers that he’s found, and the knowledge that he has, even the knowledge of their own thoughts.

Fowley professes her love for Mulder, and since we know she knows that he knows what’s going on inside her head, she must be telling the truth. She also confesses her allegiance to the Cigarette-Smoking Man, which she defends, though at least she has the grace to look a little embarrassed about it. Most importantly of all, she reveals what sounds like her primary motivation: she and Mulder can be together now that he knows the truth.

Maybe it’s just me, but I get the impression that she’s wanted to tell Mulder all of this all along but couldn’t either because to do so would be to betray her mission within the Syndicate or because she knew how Mulder would react and that she’d lose him forever. Now she’s hopeful that since he can see into her motivations and her reasons, he’ll understand and agree and they can walk into colonization hand in hand, two alien-human hybrid lovers together forever.

Does this woman creep anyone else out?

Seriously. I was having flashbacks of Kathy Bates in Misery. Don’t get me wrong; I’m not so cold-hearted that I don’t feel bad for her. But it’s plain now that she’s doing the wrong things for the wrong reasons. She loves Mulder, yes, but it’s a selfish sort of love. She doesn’t want what’s best for him, she wants him for herself. All this time she’s been plotting and scheming, or going along with someone else’s plots and schemes, in hopes that one day she could have Mulder for good with out any pesky alien colonization getting in the way.

Since Mulder plays possum the entire time she’s in the room, I’m going to put it out there and say her chances are looking slim. It’s hard to say what Mulder’s thinking at that moment, but the fact that he masks his awareness in front of Fowley tells us all we need to know. However sincere her feelings may be, he can’t trust her; she’s still on the wrong side.

By contrast, we can see Mulder struggling to focus on Scully when he realizes she’s coming into his hospital room. And what does Scully do when she reaches him? Does she pounce on his silence as an open opportunity to confess her love? No. All she does, all she beautifully, perfectly does is beg him to live. That’s it. She just needs him to hang on.

I don’t even need to comment further – the selflessness speaks for itself.


I have to say that “The Sixth Extinction” is better than I remembered. I’m still not and never will be sold on the premise. (Was the aliens’ master plan to throw the world into confusion by inundating them with conflicting doctrines? Is this a Tower of Babel scenario? Create disunity so mankind can’t get up to too much mischief?) It feels absurd in a way that even alien abductions and a conglomerate of rich old men running de-humanizing tests on an unsuspecting public didn’t. Methinks the origin of life is too vast a topic to handle in primetime. But if you’re going to do something, do it well, and the scope of this production ultimately keeps my interest even if I’m not jumping up and down with excitement.

The focus is quickly shifting from God, aliens, and the origins of the universe to Mulder and the personal consequences of his quest. Early on in the episode, even in his tired state, he seems excited about what he is, happy despite all his suffering to have become the proof he’s been searching for all this time. And yet I start to wonder.

Kritschgau: How far should it go?! How far would Mulder go?!

He’s dying. Mulder has proven many times before that he’s willing to die in this fight, to die for his cause, but does he actually want to? Is it possible that even Mulder, trapped as he is in silent torture, has a limit?

Ah, but then just when I find myself ready to get excited at the emotional possibilities… This.

Dr. Ngebe: It is the word of God.

Oh, for the love of…



Hmm. Scully’s hair grew and Mulder’s hair shrank.

Mad props to David Duchovny for best performance of a mute paralytic ever.

Whatever else we get or don’t get from this episode, Scully wielding a machete is pretty cool.

Mulder wrote that note to Skinner awfully neatly for a psychotic man writing in his own blood.

I love that brief shot we get of Skinner from the POV of Mulder’s strapped down leg. It emphasizes how vulnerable Mulder currently is.

Scully looks awfully fresh for a woman who’s just come off of a 22-hour flight.

Scully’s continuing monologue in Mulder’s direction reminds me very much of “Memento Mori” (4×15), only this time Mulder’s the one that’s dying.

The last time Scully was confronted in a car by a supernatural apparition of a black man? “Fresh Bones” (2×15). I’m not sure how to feel about the fact that I can say, “The last time.”


I wonder why Mulder attacks Skinner in order to give him the note. Perhaps he didn’t want the doctors, and therefore Diana, to know what he was thinking?

Why is Scully’s tent clean from the outside even though it’s a white tent and bugs are sticking to the inside of the material?

Kritschgau is no longer in the military so where did he find or how did he afford this equipment to test Mulder with? And how did they sneak it into the hospital?

When she threatens him with a machete, Dr. Barnes says to Scully, “Word is you’re under suspicion already!” Suspicion of what?? Killing Dr. Merkallen? He was dead before she came on the case. Killing Dr. Sandoz? She was back in D.C. by then. Is this just a haphazard attempt on Dr. Barnes’ part to deflect suspicion off of himself?

Why would Scully go all the way to the F.B.I. to find out if Mulder’s still at the hospital? You’re a doctor. Call the hospital.

Gibson Praise, well over a year ago, described what it feels like to read minds as hearing lots of different radio stations on at the same time in your head, which seems to be exactly what Mulder’s experiencing. I wonder then, why didn’t Gibson experience side effects? Was his body already used to it because he was born that way? Had his ability been triggered by something alien as well? CSM did brain surgery on Gibson back in the day much in the same way that he’s about to do it on Mulder. What would make this surgery a more successful attempt at hybridization? Is it because Mulder was previously infected with the black oil?

Best Quotes:

Scully: He’s not dying.
Skinner: I’m afraid it’s true.
Scully: He’s not dying. He is more alive than he has ever been. He’s more alive than his body can withstand and what’s causing it may be extraterrestrial in origin.
Skinner: I know. But there’s nothing to be done about it.
Scully: [Turns to leave]
Skinner: They’re going to deny you access.
Scully: Maybe as his partner… but not as his doctor.

23 responses to “The Sixth Extinction 7×3: Some truths are not for you.

  1. My lingering question is, and forgive me if it was already addressed, but I don’t understand how the rubbing of the text triggered Mulder’s psychotic breakdown.

    And you should have heard me when I realized he could read minds. I about screamed to my husband, “Now he knows about HER! That TRAITOR!” I was speaking of Fowley of course, though I used a little more colorful language.

    • I know you answered your own question in your comment for Biogenesis, but I want to add that it’s not really your fault. They WHY Mulder is affected isn’t harped on nearly as much as the HOW. I still think some explanation should have been given as to why Scully, also having been exposed the the black oil virus and its vaccine, was never affected. This was originally supposed to be a 4 episode event – perhaps if they’d been able to do that it would have been addressed?

      Oh, and I wouldn’t have been able to hear you over my own screams.

  2. Oh god, another voice over. Though I suppose I understand them in this arc, because they were to Mulder, and Mulder reads minds so… it doesn’t eliminate the cheesiness, though I am glad we are not subjected to scenes of Scully on a beach in a maxi dress as the wind blows, like in Emily. *cringes until death*

    Anyway, I’m saving the majority of my comments for the next installation because I lumped my notes together.

    However, here was my lingering question/thought: Mulder can read minds in the way Gibson Praise can… why not link the two? Ugh, I just feel like we had so much unfinished business, and the Gibson storyline could have developed in a more satisfying manner.

  3. best episode so far 🙂

  4. Great review!!! Confession time… Every morning when I get into my office I check your site from my phone while my computer is booting up to see if there is a new review. Your site is how I start off every single workday!!! Super excited for season 7. It rivals season 6 for me as far as “best season” and I’m really looking forward to what you have to say!!!

  5. It’s the middle child episode? Lolololol Omg. I agree w Emily, every week I’m so excited for your review. I can’t wait till u get to season 7 n 8 n 9 cuz most people give up reviewing by then. Hopefully you won’t!

  6. Oh, it pains me to say it, but I don’t particularly like this episode, the word mess comes to mind. It’s not enough to have this all new mythology going on, but they add in all the mystical stuff with the naked African man and the fish coming to life and all that…

    Suffice to say…not a fan.

  7. Yeah, I could have phrased that better come to think of it. 🙂

  8. I could never understand why Mulder had or dream t of being married to Fowley! Particularly when Chris C said it was in the season that M and S consummated their or became sexual couple.

    • I think Fowley represented a “normal life” or “giving up the fight” while Scully represented the “battle.” Mulder couldn’t imagine a normal life with Scully because with Scully, he couldn’t imagine giving up.

  9. I think you summed up the essential and crucial difference between Scully and Diana’s motivations concerning Mulder perfectly!
    “In real love you want the other person’s good. In romantic love, you want the other person” – Margret Anderson
    (sorry, I love quotes o-so-much 🙂

  10. Again as with Biogenesis I find this episode as a season opener somewhat lacklustre. It lacks an excitement and tension which I think is needed to grab you for the new season to come. The first half is the slowest, but for me the scenes with Fowley and Scully at Mulder’s bedside are the most engaging and emotional. I’ve never disliked Fowely as a character. I’ve never been a shipper so maybe that’s why. I found her speech somewhat moving, as with Scully’s.

    This episode reminded me of the Blessing Way, in that mulder was disabled for the episode and Scully was the focus of the action.

    Nice to see Scully wearing her glasses again. I think she looks better with less make up, but she has just been to Africa slumming it on a beach. This episode I think also starts to transition her character from skeptic to reluctant believer quite nicely ready for season 8.

    I’m finding Mark Snow’s repeated use of the movie music tiresome now. Also the constant voice overs in mythology episodes are starting to grate a bit.

    I liked the teaser, reminded me of Miricale Man is season 1.


You Know You Want To...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s