The Gift 8×11: Are you calling Mulder a liar?



We’ve had a string of episodes I don’t care for and they culminate in this, “The Gift”. I warn you here and now that I have mixed feelings about it. That said, maybe because I’ve been so bored lately, or maybe because I missed Mulder more than I realized, but seeing his face in the opening teaser is such a joy and relief. In fact, I may have teared up a little.

I used to think I hated “The Gift” but I realize now that isn’t true. I only have one problem with the gift, it’s just a really, really big problem: The entire premise rests on a storyline I despise. That’s right. Not only is Mulder missing, even if he weren’t missing, he’d be dead or dying. Mulder has a deadly brain disease that he never saw fit to tell a soul about. So go ahead, steal Mulder back from the aliens. His eventual death remains inevitable.

I’ve already expressed my opinions on this ridiculous, horrible, abomination of a distraction from the primary plot in my review for “Within” (8×1). It went a little like this.

“It’s not enough that Mulder’s gone, you’ve gotta ruin the memories too? Stop retroactively killing what little joy I found in Season 7! He was happy in Season 7! This doesn’t even fit the timeline!

Let me try to get this straight. In Season 7, Mulder and Scully are sleeping together, but she has no idea he’s traveling nearly four hundred miles round trip every weekend. Mulder’s dying of an incurable disease, but devastated as he was when his mother killed herself after hiding her illness, he plans to keep his disease a secret from Scully. Scully and Mulder are happy as clams almost all of Season 7, but what we didn’t know was that Mulder was merely hiding his suffering. He was showing “clear signs of decline” but they didn’t catch that when Mulder went to the hospital in “Signs and Wonders” (7×9) and “Brand X” (7×19), just to name a couple of times. Things are so dire that he already had his name etched on the family grave stone. And all this he manages to hide from Scully, a doctor so brilliant she can diagnose nearly any disease from a single symptom despite never having practiced medicine.

I call revisionist BS.”

My feelings remain unchanged.

So now we’re back to that, are we? Doggett has suddenly and conveniently remembered that X-Files assignment aside, he’s still charged with the task of finding Mulder. He remembers just as the audience is starting to grow restless… though I’m sure the timing of this episode and bringing David Duchovny back had nothing to do with that… or with February sweeps.

I’m sorry. I’m sorry. The thought of Mulder dying makes me cranky, that’s all.

Let me focus on the positives because, as I said, I don’t hate this episode the way I thought I did.

Like #1: Skinner and Doggett make a good team.

Every thundercloud has its rainbow and the rainbow in the storm of Mulder’s disappearance is Skinner. Our dear A.D. needed to get out more and it’s good to see him investigating a case again. This is a trend that started towards the end of Season 7 with “Brand X” and “Requiem” (7×22) and I see no reason for it to stop. Besides, he and Doggett have more onscreen chemistry than Scully and Doggett. They genuinely challenge each other instead of just assuming the position.

If we’re going to lose Scully for an episode and have an abundance of untempered testosterone, then I’m glad it went down like this. I would hate to see her absence wasted.

Like #2: The monster is unsettling.

And so are the monstrously selfish humans. Yes, the monster is gross, but more than anything it makes you wonder how far you yourself would go if you found yourself incurably ill, if you could live with saving yourself at the expense of someone else’s pain. Are the suffering entitled to the sin-eater’s help? Is their desperation excusable?

There’s a Christlike allegory in here somewhere…

He was despised and rejected by mankind, a Man of suffering, and familiar with pain. Like one from whom people hide their faces He was despised, and we held Him in low esteem. Surely He took up our pain and bore our suffering, yet we considered Him punished by God, stricken by Him, and afflicted. But He was pierced for our transgressions, He was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was on Him, and by His wounds we are healed. Isaiah 53:3-5 (NIV)

The difference is that while Christ died willingly, the sin-eater has no choice. He’s dying a constant death because no one is brave enough to bear their own suffering, not when there’s someone else who can pay the price instead.

It may sound like I’m pulling this out of nowhere, but I think this is actually a parallel that writer Frank Spotnitz wanted us to see, especially in the scene of Mrs. Hangemuhl’s deliverance.

Watching the sin-eater stretch its mouth to eat her alive while her husband recites The Lord’s Prayer in the background, I’ll admit it’s pretty disturbing. It’s supposed to be.

Like #3: Mulder makes sense.

His dying makes no sense, but if he were dying, it would be completely in character for Mulder to destroy the means of his own salvation if by doing so he could save someone else.

One thing the series has lost sight of as of late is the original vision Chris Carter had of Mulder and Scully as romantic heroes, and I do mean romantic in the literary sense. Their main purpose is to seek the truth and to do right even if it costs them. To that end, Scully was originally imbued with a strong sense of justice, Mulder with compassion. Sometimes Mulder empathizes with victims to an almost frustrating extent, but that’s who he is. He’s a compassionate human being who would rather die than force someone else to suffer for him.

Heck, when Scully was dying in “Redux II” (5×2) he wouldn’t let her take the blame for his killing a man who was spying on him. He wouldn’t let her reputation suffer for him even though she wouldn’t be alive to feel it. That’s my Mulder.

Like #4: Doggett bonds with Mulder.

This is The X-Files. You don’t ever have to have met to develop a spiritual connection.

Somehow, despite having been a confirmed skeptic as recently as the last episode, Doggett puts together the pieces of this case so well you would think he was reading from Mulder’s playbook. While that does move my eyebrow up toward my hairline a tad, I’m glad that if Doggett finally experienced the paranormal in his own person, it’s Mulder who led him there. Mulder is the emotional and spiritual center of the X-Files, which started out as the expression and fulfilment of his own passion, the vehicle for his quest. He’s the one who initiated Scully on this journey of discovery, and it’s only fitting that he should initiate Doggett, even if it’s in his absence.

Doggett also finishes what Mulder was trying to do. Through Doggett’s death he saves the sin-eater. Ah, there’s that cycle again: death – resurrection – salvation.

In saving the sin-eater an emotional link is created between Mulder and Doggett. Mulder shoots it to save it, Doggett stands up for it and is shot. I’ve avoided this episode for so long that I didn’t remember the ending. I had forgotten that Doggett died and came back. I like it.

Mulder’s a good man. John Doggett’s a good man too.


I’m both relieved that they brought Mulder back and more than slightly resentful that they brought him back this way and to serve the purposes of this storyline. But it is what it is and if it has to be, at least “The Gift” makes better use of the characters than the last several episodes.

Well, most of the characters. Mulder could’ve remained completely unseen and the story wouldn’t have suffered at all.

For the love of all that is Scully, stop wasting David Duchovny’s eleven episodes!!!


The Peanut Gallery:

All this time and no one had given Mulder’s apartment a proper search before?

So, in order to be healed, you get eaten and come back as monster vomit.

The monster vomit and the yellowish underground caves remind me of “Gender Bender” (1×13). That was my very first episode of The X-Files.

We’re getting so much of the Lone Gunmen this season that I’m starting to feel spoiled. Another silver lining to the Mulder is Missing rainbow.

There’s a great shot director Kim Manners does in the hospital scene. We can see Mr. and Mrs. Hangemuhn lovingly celebrating her recovery in Doggett’s reflection. That’s a beautiful shot.

That rustic woman’s accent throws me off.

Best Quotes:

Byers: We learned what we could. This is somewhat short notice, of course.

Frohike: And a little outside our area of expertise.

Langly: Plus the fact we were sleeping.

Doggett: You wearing pants, Langly?

Langly: Uh… yeah.


11 responses to “The Gift 8×11: Are you calling Mulder a liar?

  1. I agree with everything you said. I remember being so angry the first time I watched this one. It actually is a pretty solid story…I just hate the whole Mulder illness side of it. That whole plot line was such a waste of time. Is it just there to make me feel better about Scully and friends not looking for him? It doesn’t. So much could have been done to further the ACTUAL plot of the x-files: the conspiracy. But no. Why would they want to do that?

    Such a waste of DD’s episodes. And the fact that Scully isn’t even IN this one. I mean, M/S chemistry is magic. Did they really think that everyone just wanted to see Mulder like this? No. We want Mulder AND Scully, even if it’s just flash backs. We want Scully looking for Mulder. I feel like I’ve complained about this so much already that I’m just going to stop now because it feels repetitive.

    • If ALL of our complaints feel repetitive it’s because they kept batting the issue around Season 8 without actually taking it anywhere. It was meant to create suspense and tension but I think what it mostly succeeded in doing was creating frustration.

  2. Pingback: Empedolces 8×17: The pizza man is not above suspicion. | Musings of an X-Phile

  3. Pingback: Vienen 8×16: How about a twenty count? | Musings of an X-Phile

  4. “All this time and no one had given Mulder’s apartment a proper search before?”

    Doggett searched Fox’ apartment before. In an earlier episode where Dana sleeps on Fox’ bed to quell here missing him, Doggett suddenly enters. Dana tried to explain here being there by telling she’s there to feed the fish, by while saying that, clearly can’t find the fish food. Doggett, seeing that, directly replies that the food can be found in a specific drawer.

    • Good catch! He did know where things were. Then again, the apartment didn’t look searched at all. And it wasn’t searched thoroughly or else he wouldn’t have found that gun in such a relatively simple hiding place.

  5. I think you wrote this in an earlier Season 8 review, but The Lone Gunmen suddenly are the go-to characters for paranormal knowledge now. I guess someone has to do it since the usual source is busy being tortured/tested at the moment. And we all love Lone Gunmen scenes enough to overlook this. In rewatching, the early Skype/Facetime tech really stands out 🙂 Pretty decent episode overall.

  6. I thought it was a solid and creepy episode. The vomiting scene raised my eyebrows a bit. 🙂

    I thought the Mulder tie in was a waste of his screen time as it was all flashback but it does bring him back into the series for a later ep I’m assuming?

    I liked Patrick in this as he gets to show some chops and work with Pileggi again…they DO work good together as you say.

    The only thing I wish they would have shown is the consequences of the shooting of Doggett. They just end it after he is resurrected and then he’s just…gone. These selfish goobs just outright murdered him! Of course he isn’t dead or injured so how would you prove anything? If it was me I’d be looking for anything to book them on.

  7. . This might be even better than Roadrunners. I love the intrigue and mystery, as well as Mulder’s appearances, exactly because he does serve the story. One of the show’s better endings too – very poetic, as you stated. Haters of s.8 should really watch this episode.

    I admire how far season 8 pushes things as well, for better or worse. Scully the believer, the slug god, the munchkin who crawls up peoples asses, and Doggett being vomited back to life. Could it get any more mondo bizzarro? And then season 9 comes along like a cold cup of tea, let’s not talk about that

  8. I really like this episode, despite the lack of Scully. Maybe because Mulder makes up for Scully. I like it more than “Via Negative”, which is essentially a the same formula: a Doggett & Skinner episode, again written by Frank Spotnitz.

    The plot and monster in this is interesting. Although I think the monster would have looked better without the jeans, and he/it has a good body despite taking everybodys’ illnesses. The mood, atmosphere, lighting were all creepy and classic x files. The underground lair reminded me of the one in season one’s “GenderBender”.

    Doggett seeing Mulder’s ghost at the end can mean only one thing…


You Know You Want To...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s