Audrey Pauley 9×13: You’re not giving up, are you?

“Audrey Pauley” is one of the few Season 9 episodes that I have a distinct memory of. Okay, wait. It’s one of the few Season 9 episodes that I have a distinct memory of liking.

Steven Maeda seems to have a knack for writing for Doggett and Reyes. He gave us “4-D” (9×5) earlier this season, which I also thought was sci-fi of the less paranormal sort that seemed to suit our new leads just fine. It also showed us a deep connection between these two characters, heavily iced with flirting, that made their partnership that much more interesting to watch.

He’s done it again here, with a case that carries a lot of real world weight and some intense flirting. Whoa, Reyes. Why not just invite yourself in? It would take fewer words.

But the really real truth is that Reyes is at her best as a character when she’s playing off of Doggett. As I discussed ad nauseam in the review for “Hellbound” (9×4), she isn’t given much by way of her own backstory or personal motivation outside of her history with Doggett and desire to help him.

That said, what we finally see in her character for the first time in this episode is that she’s actually a decent investigator. She solves this mystery. She doesn’t get away with feeling her way to the truth.

Doggett also solves the case on his end and he does it without having to turn into a believer like Mulder or Reyes. Doggett’s just a guy who refuses to give up on his loved one and turns every stone over looking for a miracle or at least a way to help her. There’s nothing about his response to the situation that requires him to suddenly wholeheartedly believe in the paranormal. But he’s emotional and vulnerable and desperate, which makes him open to the truth when he hears it from Audrey Pauley. He doesn’t have to completely understand or make sense of it, but he knows something’s up and that’s enough for him to hold on.

Yep. The characterization is strong with this one.

The plot, though…

The concept is memorable, I will say that. There’s something truly frightening about the idea of seeing a loved one brain dead or in a coma or vegetative state. It’s almost worse than outright death in that you don’t know whether or not they’re suffering and the weight of the responsibility for their welfare is a heavy one. This isn’t just a nightmare for Reyes, it’s a nightmare for Doggett who wants to do right by Reyes and is horrified at the fear that in listening to the doctors he might actually be doing her harm.

And again, I think theoretical or reality based stories like this are the best vehicles for Reyes and Doggett. But again, the script feels a little rushed. Or maybe there wasn’t enough time to sharpen the more obscure edges of the plot and emphasize Doggett and Reyes’ budding romance.

Audrey Pauley is a simple-minded woman who is also a savant of some kind since she can build an exact scale replica of the hospital she lives and works at. Audrey has a quiet corner of her mind where she likes to go that looks an awful lot like the hospital dollhouse that looks an awful lot like the hospital itself. One day, brain dead patients started taking refuge in Audrey’s mind and she didn’t know how to get their souls out of her mental dollhouse and back to their bodies. But then, she was killed by a villainous doctor and Reyes, who had been brain dead, was able to jump out of Audrey’s mind and back into her own body.

Say what now?

Issues of accuracy in the depiction of brain death and organ transplantation aside, how and why did Audrey manage to trap these people’s souls in her own mind? And I’m still not sure I understand why if Reyes had jumped into the abyss while Audrey was still alive she would have died, but once Audrey was dying/dead she jumped and lived. Audrey was both keeping them alive and somehow keeping them from living again?

On top of that, while I really enjoyed the villainous doctor, why was he a villain? Was it just that he wanted to harvest organs for transplant? From what little I know, the doctors (always plural) in charge of declaring a patient brain dead are never those involved in donation and transplantation; it’s a conflict of interest. But for the sake of argument, he thought these patients would die anyway so he wanted to speed up the process of their death in order to save others instead? If so, why did he choose Reyes who wasn’t severely injured? Was there money changing hands somewhere for these organs?

I don’t know, but it seems to me he’s just a sadist. He kills with too much aplomb to be anything else. Maybe he just gets a thrill out of secretly killing helpless people.

Either way, that’s not nearly as important as receiving confirmation that Doggett’s over his Scully crush. Good riddance.


When this first aired, I remember being more than a tad resentful that a story like this wasn’t used for Mulder and Scully in lackluster Season 7. I knew the 1013 writing staff had it in them. Where had all the cowboys gone?

But even as much as I enjoy this one, it’s a sad reminder that the Doggett and Reyes’ relationship is moving fast for a reason. It’s time to wrap this show up and we’ll never know whether truly memorable television could have been made out of this partnership. I still say they had potential, perhaps not for magic, but for something interesting to watch. They have a real connection in their scenes together, not that I’m sold on a second romance in the basement office. It’s getting a little hot and heavy down there.


P.S. If someone knows of a fanfic that substitutes Mulder and Scully for Doggett and Reyes in this ep, holla at your girl.

Valley of the Dollhouse:

That electrical death looks awfully painful. God forbid taking someone off of life support would result in such a thing.

The actress who plays Audrey Pauley, Tracey Ellis, also starred in “Oubliette” (3×8).

It’s Will’s mom from The Fresh Prince!

Dr. Scully’s reaction to Reyes waking up from brain death is awfully subdued. A few misdiagnoses aside, such a thing has never happened. Reyes’ brain should be studied for science.

Total resurrection is another story, however.

If they were going to harvest Reyes’ heart, they wouldn’t take her off life support. They’d want her heart beating when they performed the procedure. You know, in case you were planning to perform a transplant yourself.

The doctor stayed in the room with Audrey after he killed her for far too long.

Best Quotes:

Reyes: So, big plans for the weekend?
Doggett: Oh, huge. Microwave pizza, satellite TV.
Reyes: Wow. Thanks for making my life sound exciting. Maybe we both need pets. They say people with pets live longer.
Doggett: I was thinking about getting a cat.
Reyes: There’s dog people and there’s cat people. You are a dog person, John.
Doggett: How do you figure?
Reyes: You’re faithful, you’re dependable, you’re without guile, you’re very comfortable to be around. So why a cat?
Doggett: Low maintenance. They don’t expect much from you, so you can’t disappoint ’em.
Reyes: I don’t see you ever disappointing anyone, John.

19 responses to “Audrey Pauley 9×13: You’re not giving up, are you?

  1. This is one of those episodes that I feel is a hidden gem. It doesn’t show up screaming in everyone’s top ten list but it’s just off to the side, slightly in the background. I’m not sure what it is that appeals to me – it’s pretty stark and colourless – but I really enjoyed the story and Reyes, in particular. I have to agree with you on the electrical death – ouch! I’ll pass even if the patient ends up looking content after being zapped. And I know Doggett & Reyes will never be Mulder & Scully but I’m shipping them, too. That was a cute scene that you quoted in your review.

    • When Season 9 first aired, I remember this being the first episode that I considered a solid “like”. It has emotional impact.

      I didn’t really ship Doggett and Reyes, per se. It was more like I expected and wanted to see them happy eventually, but I wasn’t emotionally invested in their budding romance either. They did have real chemistry, though. And their scenes together were their best ones.

  2. That fanfic would be on point. You should write it!

  3. I like that Reyes was the focus, but I found it sad that she is basically made important through Doggett. This would have been a good opportunity for us to learn about Reyes through her family. Conveniently they live in Mexico City and they didn’t make it out in time before the episode ended.

    I don’t hate Doggett and Reyes together, I just find it a bit galling that they were so against anything happening between Mulder and Scully, even when they were together, and now they are practically shoving Doggett and Reyes together.

    Will’s mom from Fresh Prince! I knew she looked familiar.

    • Reyes was a missed opportunity. And it’s not Annabeth Gish’s fault because she acted her wonderfully, especially in this episode and “4-D”. Maybe if the ratings had been better and they had more time to flesh her out… if they didn’t have to think about wrapping up the entire series… she could have gotten her due.

  4. Pingback: Season 9 Wrap Up – There’s a lot of crap to cut through. | Musings of an X-Phile

  5. This is one of my favorite episodes. And I’m not really sure I can put my finger on why. I guess it’s because Reyes is just awesome in it.

    And with this episode, everyone who’s been assigned to The X-Files has been in a coma/brain dead at some point…

  6. This episode made me cry, it was so emotional. It was a hidden gem, I agree. Love Reyes and Dogget, they are a great couple.

  7. Hey hello!!
    There is a fanfiction
    Pauley Audrey
    Audrey Pauley rewritted for Mulder and Scully.

    I love your blog.

  8. Pingback: Brand X 7×19: They say these things kill people. | Musings of an X-Phile

  9. This is one of my favourite episodes from season 9. It has a pathos and a nice story which is wrapped up in a satisfying way. It was nice to see Scully & Doggett working as a pair again. It would have been good to see more of that season. The actress playing Audrey was excellent, and I know she was reused from season’s 3 “Oubliette”, but she fit the part perfectly. I like the cinematography of the episode, a blue/green hue, which adds a nice distinction to it.

    My only criticism is that the chemistry / love aspect between John & Monica is played up too much for my liking. It took seasons to develop Mulder & Scully’s and it feels rushed and forced by the writers. They didn’t need to do this. And why is Scully calling Doggett “Agent” Doggget? Good acting by all in this episode.


Leave a Reply to Amanda Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s