En Ami 7×15: Here’s a story to warm the cockles of your heart.


The devil went down to Virginia.

The title basically gives the crux of this episode away. Is C.G.B. Spender, aka Cigarette-Smoking Man, acting “en ami,” “as a friend?” Or is he, as ever, Scully’s enemy?

When “En Ami” first aired I remember liking it alright, but overall feeling a little disappointed. I’m happy to report that it improves upon rewatching, provided one keeps one’s expectations in check; this isn’t designed to be fright fest or a fast-paced adventure or even a true mythology episode. It’s really a quiet study in psychological intrigue. Somehow or other, CSM is able to wear down Scully’s mind to the point where she believes him. Him! A confirmed liar and the father of them.

In a welcome turn, Scully is the object of everyone’s attention and affection this episode. Though the real stars of “En Ami” are Scully’s breasts.

I kid.

No, I don’t.

A few gratuitous shots of Scully’s cleavage aside, it feels good to watch her launch her own investigation for the first time in a long time. Well, I guess it’s not really an investigation. CSM sets Scully up from the beginning by orchestrating a series of events designed to trick her into showing up at a particular meeting place, otherwise, he wouldn’t be able to get his hands on the cure to his disease.

He starts by curing Jason, a little boy diagnosed with cancer whose parents don’t believe in traditional medicine for religious reasons. Jason is visited one night by “angels” who implant a chip in his neck, triggering his immediate recovery. CSM draws Scully’s attention to this little miracle, knowing that because of the chip she’d had in her own neck and her battle against cancer after she had it removed, she wouldn’t be able to ignore the implications.

Once Scully is duly intrigued, CSM announces his presence, telling Scully that Jason isn’t the first and he doesn’t have to be the last. In what feels like a clear-cut case of the devil masquerading as God, CSM claims that he has the cure for cancer and he’ll give it to Scully and only to Scully. Enough of that Mulder. He doesn’t know what’s good for him.

The feeling is mutual as Mulder is done listening to CSM and warns Scully that she shouldn’t fall for his mind games either. Here’s where Scully gets really radical, not because she decides to go on a road trip with CSM, but because she lies to Mulder and thinks she can get away with it.

Now, I’m all for Scully ditching Mulder. Heaven knows he deserves it after the untold times he’s left her flapping in the wind of ignorance while he ran headlong into danger. But did Scully really think Mulder wouldn’t catch on immediately? Mulder, who as far back as “Paper Clip” (3×2) she had a psychic connection with. Notice she can’t look him in the face and lie, she has to do it over an answering machine.

No, it seems like a battle she knew she’d lose; she was merely buying time to get away with CSM. The benefit her foolishness affords us is a great scene in Scully’s hallway between Mulder and Scully’s building super. Also, there’s a fabulous moment when Skinner is on the phone with Scully and Mulder reaches for the phone, but she hangs up rather than talk to him. Burn.

But I’m getting off topic. Back to the plot.

Scully and CSM run off together and leave Mulder pacing the floor with worry. CSM introduces Scully to another one of his success stories, Marjorie Butters, a one hundred and eighteen-year-old woman who doesn’t look a day over seventy. How we went from the cure for cancer to the secret of eternal life, I don’t know. But for some reason, Scully the doctor is convinced, not by scientific proof, but by anecdotal evidence. Maybe she wants to believe.

Now that she does believe, and this is a jump in logic I’m never quite able to make, CSM also convinces her that there’s a contact they have to meet who holds the science that Scully needs to save the world. I thought CSM already had the cure? No? Well, I’m going to give the plot the benefit of the doubt and assume that CSM had access to the chips, but not the (alien) science behind the technology, and that’s what he promised Scully.

Anywho, after a very skeevy moment where Scully falls dead asleep in the car and CSM puts gloves on before staring at her… dangerously, they arrive at a quaint little hotel in the idyllic middle of nowhere. Did CSM drug her? Please, for the love of applesauce, somebody tell me changed her own clothes and put herself in bed. ‘Cause Scully and I are both a little freaked out right now.

It’s over a candlelit dinner when The Girls and Scully, their co-star, are told by CSM that this technology will not only cure cancer but it’s the cure for all that ills. No one comes out and uses the word “panacea,” but I suppose that would make the idea sound farfetched. And no one wants The X-Files to sound farfetched. Perhaps, though, this explains Marjorie Butters.

The more interesting thing is that CSM spills his guts. Well, okay. I’m overstating that. But he does reveal a secret longing for human love. Supposedly, near death’s door as he is, he wants to leave behind something good. He regrets choosing a life of bitter loneliness. Whether he says this out of genuine remorse, or whether this is part of his scheme to trick Scully, or whether he has unrealistic hopes of seducing Scully, you be the judge.

We do know he’s up to something, however, as Black-Haired Man from Fight the Future is back and secretly doing his dirty work. Scully also has a secret admirer who slips her a note in the restaurant, telling her to meet him at dawn. Actually, he calls it “first light,” but we all know that’s purely for flair.

Scully goes to meet him out on the lake and he turns out to be “Cobra,” a man wanted by the federal government and who was involved in some shadow project at the Department of Defense. As Mulder and the Lone Gunmen find out separately, “Cobra” has been emailing Scully for the past six months. He thought she was emailing him back. She wasn’t. Somebody, who probably looks a lot like CSM, hacked her computer, intercepted the emails and responded as Scully. That same somebody set up this meeting at the quaint little hotel in the idyllic middle of nowhere.

“Cobra” gives Scully a disk that supposedly contains the secret to utopia on it and drops some not so subtle hints about he and Scully creating their own private utopia. He’ll have to make do with that last glance at our fair heroine, alas, as Black-Haired Man promptly shoots him from his hidden position in the woods almost as soon as he hands over the disk. He takes aim at Scully too – after all, all they wanted was the disk and Scully was merely the lure to draw Cobra out – but the shot we hear ring out kills him instead. It looks like CSM has a soft spot for Scully after all. Whether he intended to save her from the beginning… I have my doubts. But it would appear that CSM’s more emotionally attached to his sworn enemies than his minions. Funny how relationships can develop like that.

Safe and sound, Scully hands the disk over to CSM who duly gives it back to her because, after all, the whole point was to get this information into Scully’s hands. Back in Mulder’s apartment, Scully looks hopefully up at Mulder who was ready to call out the National Guard over his missing partner. The expression on his face as he looks up and away from her is priceless. He says nothing with his mouth but his eyes say, “I can’t even talk to you right now.” All’s not forgiven yet.

Scully has incurred Mulder’s ire to no avail. There’s nothing on the disk. CSM switched them somehow, giving Scully a blank disk and keeping the disk with the information on it he needs to save his own life. That’s all this was ever about. The fake office building, the fake miracles, all of it. It was an elaborate rouse to save himself.

Why, then, does he toss the disk into the water? Could it be that not everything he told Scully was a lie? Maybe he doesn’t really want to live, not if he continues to live a meaningless and lonely life.


Whew! I know I don’t usually recap this much. But with so much intrigue, it seemed easier to combine my comments with the plot for the most part. This isn’t a traditional mythology episode, but there are almost as many twists and turns.

The ambiguity of it all is actually one of this episodes weak points, or strong points depending on how you look at it. Back in the day, The X-Files used to leave its audience hanging on the regular. This was our first and only offering of a script from William B. Davis (heavily edited by Frank Spotnitz) who, understandably, wanted to get inside CSM’s head a little bit. And, even more understandably, wanted some more screentime with Gillian Anderson. The thing is, CSM tells us things about himself, but it’s hard to decide which lie to believe. In the end, we’re not any closer to knowing who he is. Unless, of course, like me, you think he truly is a lonely man with a soft spot for Scully and Mulder.

As I said before, it’s a quiet, thoughtful sort of episode without any fireworks or mayhem. But I like it because even if it doesn’t offer concrete insight, it gives me several good laughs and moments of tension.

Hee-Haws –

  • The Lone Gunmen in drag
  • “Do you know how many people have died in there?”
  • Mulder so ticked at Scully he can’t even look in her direction

Uh-Ohs –

  • Black-Haired Man masquerades as the Mailman
  • Did CSM just see Scully naked???

There’s a bit where CSM tries to psycho-analyze Scully that I could have done without. However, at least there’s some emotional continuity with “Never Again” (4×13). Not that CSM knows Scully as well as he thinks he does, not based on her eyebrow raise after he accuses her of living “a life alone.” Hmm…

Long story not so short, I think it’s good. The plot can be a little hard to follow, it’s hard to believe Scully would fall for CSM’s lies on so little evidence, and it’s a little tame, so I’m torn between grades. With the aftertaste of “First Person Shooter” (7×13) still in my mouth, I’m almost inclined to upgrade it in comparison. But I think I’ll have to go with a:


Blank Disks:

Seriously though, I love Mulder’s wounded housewife routine. “Where were you? You should have called!”

You really can’t blame CSM for taking a shot. Gillian Anderson looks especially gorgeous this episode. I’m glad they gave her the chance to dress up at least once in the series.

Scully makes secret tape recordings for Mulder. Tapes. Remember those?

That scene where Scully’s asleep in the car with CSM and he reaches over to touch her reminds me, perversely, of “Pusher” (3×17).

This was director Rob Bowman’s final episode before leaving the show.

Scully’s motivations – Maybe she falls for it all so easily because CSM knew which buttons to push. He focused on her compassion as a doctor, her sense of justice as a law enforcement agent, her curiosity as a scientist, and her empathy as a cancer survivor. No wonder he went to her and not to Mulder.

Best Quotes:

Mulder: I’ve just got to know whether it was Roma Downey or Della Reese.


Scully: What the hell are you doing?

CSM: God’s work, what else?


Apartment Manager: Tenants like having an FBI agent in the building. Gives them a sense of security.

Mulder: Do you know how many people have died in there?

Apartment Manager: Oh, we don’t really talk about that.


Mulder: Who the hell is Cobra? Scully would have told me about him.

Langly: Well, it looks like she’s gone to great lengths to keep this from you.

Mulder: I don’t believe that. She knows that I’d find her, no matter what. {Editor’s Note: He can back that up too, y’all.}


39 responses to “En Ami 7×15: Here’s a story to warm the cockles of your heart.

  1. Excellent review as usual
    Thank you

  2. This is one of my top 10 episodes, and I’m not altogether sure why. Maybe part of it’s due to Duchovny’s sexy hate-stare he flashes at Scully at the end. 😉

    Really though, there’s something very gripping to me in the scene where CSM is explaining the disc to Scully in the restaurant.

    • Someone on twitter said this was one of their faves too. I’m glad to see it get some love.

      My favorite part of this episode has to be Mulder’s worry/irritation over Scully. It’s hilarious to me, for some reason.

  3. So I must be slow, but I never caught the enemy pun in en ami. God, now I feel dumb. You win.

    Also, I can’t wait till you get to Requiem/Season 8 so you can comment on how or even whether this episode ties into a certain plotline. And make fun of said plotline.

    • I didn’t catch on when it first aired either. I can’t remember when I finally did…

      Personally, seriously, the closer I get the Requiem the queasier I feel. Why is Chris Carter determined to give me indigestion? Why???

    • “Also, I can’t wait till you get to Requiem/Season 8 so you can comment on how or even whether this episode ties into a certain plotline. And make fun of said plotline.”

      Prophetic much?

      • Heather (yes the same one)

        Dang it. Really? In season 11, we are dealing with this bullshit. No no no no no. Ahem. I’m done. It’s bad because the plot is so bad yet the Mulder/Scully dynamic is almost back. And it makes you yearn for the old days.

  4. Look, you can at least look forward to the glorious punching out an auditor dialogue at the beginning of the episode though…

  5. Scully’s breasts are the actual stars of this episode. Were truer words ever spoken? Scully looks fabulous in this entire episode.

    I do like this episode despite the creepiness of the whole “romantic weekend away” feel (he changed her clothes while she was passed out!! Scully should have shot him) and how easily Scully falls for CSM and doesn’t try in the slightest to keep Mulder up on this because…a weekend away with your sworn enemy?? Although Mulder can’t say he doesn’t have it coming.

    However, this episode is tainted for me by the actual creepiness of WBD. It’s hard for me to not think about that while watching this.

    • There is an underlying creep factor here, as though CSM were tying to move in on Mulder’s territory. Considering what we already suspect and is confirmed later about he and Mulder’s relationship, it’s especially creepy.

      From what I’ve read, Scully was initially supposed to fall for CSM’s lies even more easily, but they reworked it. He was supposed to be a super seductive manipulator.

  6. This is actually one of my favorite episodes. My favorite part of the show (aside from Mulder and Scully edging out Lois Lane and Clark Kent as my favorite couple of all time) was the cancer arch; I loved that WBD brought it back so late in the game. Also, my nerdy MS in Experimental Psychology-ness makes me LOVE the psychological warfare and questions/ambiguity of motives of this episode. No, nothing’s blowing up and there are no ghosts anywhere, but this episode always has me on the edge of my seat. Also, I just love the moment in the car seen when Cancer Man is psychoanalyzing Scully and her relationship with Mulder and she has that little smirk when he talks about how she won’t let herself love Mulder. GA played it perfectly. Scully was non-verbally saying, “if only you knew, Cancer Man, if only you knew.”

    It always creeps me out that CSM has this weird/GROSS attraction to the mother of his grandkid. UHhHHHggggggggg.

    As to there relationship, I totally think they got together together around the time that they started conspicuously showing up at crime scenes separately, like they wanted to make a point that they hadn’t driven over together from one of their homes that morning.

  7. Pingback: Season 7 Wrap Up – You don’t want me looking foolish. | Musings of an X-Phile

  8. Pingback: Milagro 6×18: I live in my head. | Musings of an X-Phile

  9. Pingback: Triangle 6×3: I would’ve never seen you again, but you believed me. | Musings of an X-Phile

  10. Pingback: Jump the Shark 9×15: Guys like that, they live forever. | Musings of an X-Phile

  11. Great review! I like this episode, but my big problem with it is why did Scully hand over the disk right away? Even if she was duped for the whole ep, she just got shot at and should be back to this-guy-can’t-be-trusted mode. She easily could have insisted on viewing it first since that was the deal. Am I missing something?

    • It’s been a while, but I don’t think you’re missing anything. I’m trying to remember… maybe we’re supposed to believe she didn’t see a way out of handing him the disk without risking getting herself killed?

  12. Did anyone else feel a similarity to the theme of Hannibal, as in the film with Julianne Moore? theres this similar seduction kind of seduction by someone the agent knows to be a liar, the semi sexual undertones, dressing up for dinner… luckily CM wasn’t eating someone’s brains, but he was messing with Scully’s head…

    • I definitely see what you mean. And considering how Scully was conceived of as a version of Clarice Starling, I was suspicious enough to do a little Google searching. But alas, “En Ami” came out before Hannibal… that doesn’t mean someone wasn’t inspired by the books, though.

  13. Pingback: My Struggle III: Who or what had reason to put her through the trauma? | Musings of an X-Phile

  14. I love this episode. It’s one of the best of season seven. As William B. Davis says, I’ve always thought Scully and CSM (sorry CGB Spender doesn’t have the same ring to it) never had enough scenes together. Scully’s interactions and facial expressions with the CSM are perfect. The loathing cannot be contained.

    I love the teaser. It’s raining, atmospheric, and creepy. The storyline is strong throughout. It’s a shame he didn’t write another episode. The score also adds to the tension in this episode.

    It’s nice to Scully in a dress.

    Are Mail boxes really like that in America? So large that anyone can fish out your post if they wanted too. Luckily in the U.K. they have a thin slit so no one can bet at your post.

    What’s with the Lone Gunnman’s “disguise” ? I understand they were trying to look like each other but why? They don’t pull it off. It they wanted to disguise themselves they could have tried something completely different.

    Rob Bowman’s last episode. You will be missed.

    Love the pissed off silent treatment Mulder gives Scully at the end.

    Why did CSM throw the disc in the water after all the trouble to get it? Did he cure himself? I guess not judging by Requiem 7X22.

    How many people have died in Scully’s apartment? Let’s see, Melissa Scully, Donnie Phaster, who else?


    • This is a good question. Really, I can only think of those deaths at the moment. But I may still be distracted by the Season 11 finale. If we’re talking about shootings, spyings, and infiltrations, it would be a much higher number.

  15. Knowing what we know now (or do we really- I kind of pretend it didn’t happen) this Episode is really hard to watch now.

    Do we really witniss here how CSM impregnates Scully with Mulders brother using SCIENCE- Please say it isn’t so!

  16. Why was this Rob Bowman’s last episode? I looked at his Wiki filmography and there’s a big gap in the 2000s. What happened? Him and Kim Manners were so brilliant.

  17. I just got to this episode on my re-watch, and watching it post season 11 is pretty creepy and seriously weird. CC has really ruined what I can’t help but feel was the initial intention of this episode coming from WBD… to reveal a more human side of CSM. In the old days, no matter how you read this episode or how weirdly confusing it was, it pointed towards some kind of (perhaps misguided) humanity in him. Now… it is sad to think that the whole plot can just be seen as a smokescreen for medical rape. And even more annoyingly, the plot actually makes more sense if you believe season 11. Which I am trying not to. The whole nonsense does this episode an enormous disservice. Poor en ami.

  18. I just caught a small continuity error. When Scully wrote on the envelope, she started with “Fox Mulder.” When the bad guy who retrieved it from the mailbox, the envelope had “c/o Agent Fox Mulder” on the top line. It seems a little sloppy.

    It doesn’t seem like Salome or anyone else is using this blog anymore and that makes me sad.

You Know You Want To...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s